@chadkimball1 "Following a 2.5-hour choir practice attended by 61 persons, including a symptomatic index patient, 32 confirmed and 20 probable secondary COVID-19 cases occurred (attack rate = 53.3% to 86.7%); three patients were hospitalized, and two died.
@chadkimball1 Think of the force/inhaling it takes to project a voice. Imagine an entire choir doing that & someone has the virus. An infected person in a choir is one of the most dangerously efficient ways to spread this. It just makes sense. https:/
@chadkimball1 It’s about science: https://t.co/loiizcNRnB
@LincolnFresno @GarryBredefeld Delaying the spread of the virus can save 100s of thousands of lives between now and April. Evidence of spread at churches was your other question? That one was nailed down pretty early in the pandemic. https://t.co/LeFPozZF
NHigh SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020 https://t.co/M9BgQdiI0D Like they do in England? Where infection rate is currently 70% higher and where 40% more, per head, have died?
RT @ProfJWR: @heraldscotland High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020 htt…
@heraldscotland High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020 https://t.co/tHUgsvMKRb
Choir practice attendees had multiple opportunities for droplet transmission from close contact or fomite transmission (9), and the act of singing itself might have contributed to SARS-CoV-2 transmission. https://t.co/XSqGxIr1SY
But, you know... singing is spreading. https://t.co/7lbALLzjVS
RT @AliNouriPhD: 4. CDC: Another choir super-spreading event: following practice, 32 confirmed; 20 probable secondary cases. "The act of si…
@ampthebassist @Dafuq891 @sltrib Sure, I spoke into my phone saying 'case studies of church super spreader events' and the lord Google delivereth results... This is one: https://t.co/fPwlH3QGxb
@paulwadstrom @TobbeStrom @Claeskeson Att ropa och skrika och sjunga i 90+ minuter är INTE att rekommendera. https://t.co/vIvIQv2E9c
High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020 | MMWR https://t.co/KIcYJcgmnP
@rgennaro67 @Google @Apple Following a 2.5-hour choir practice attended by 61 persons, including a symptomatic index patient, 32 confirmed and 20 probable secondary COVID-19 cases occurred (attack rate = 53.3% to 86.7%); three patients were hospitalized, a
@COtacitus @TSicarii @SteveTiger999 @DrOakley1689 OK, you're right, the original newspaper reports I read seemed to suggest no one in attendance was known to be ill, but in reality there was: https://t.co/Jmd796Tus3
RT @EdMalagaTrillo: @edgarchuta Hay muchos 👇👇👇 https://t.co/S6MAhaLqj7
@edgarchuta Hay muchos 👇👇👇
@benparish @jorrylad @alex_brian92 @MattHancock Or singing or talking https://t.co/RFDwvhdnCU
Por este tipo de twits es que sigo al doctor Málaga
Contagios por aerosoles en espacios confinados
@funambuline 👏 @elpais_espana ! (Et avec un autre exemple cité très intéressant pour les chœurs : [Hamner et al. High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2020;69:
Traducción de este artículo: no abran las iglesias, son focos de contagio masivo, puede ser catastrófico. Lo que reportan los gringos ya se sabía por los reportes desde Korea. #SinCienciaNoHayFuturo
RT @EdMalagaTrillo: @EGrandyM4 👇👇👇
@EGrandyM4 👇👇👇
👇👇👇
@KeetjeEllis @cnlester Article posted 28th Oct according to the URL. The choir example was much earlier (Mar: https://t.co/82invyieYX) and used here as an illustration I think, though probably inputted into the model’s data set. Where did you find the cont
@chrislhayes At one extreme, there’s singing together — highly contagious. (A lot like attending rallies of a certain politician) https://t.co/rdK7KHfD4Q https://t.co/LJtJiX8Zou
@CT_Bergstrom @electiontrackin @GidMK It is based on a quantal rates derived from the Skagitt Chorale outbreak, which generated 970 quanta per hour while singing and infected ~80% of the chorus in 2.5 hours. To be fair, we don't know the quantal rates of o
@kpk From that thread:
@nickgillespie @GavinNewsom Probably based on this event... https://t.co/OhOT1CpQQe
Yeah, so crazy considering... https://t.co/OhOT1CpQQe
@AgnesWold @Anders74485303 Hittar nog inte den artikeln eller också minns jag de exakta siffrorna fel men här är två andra artiklar som visar på liknande resultat. Dock stämmer 80 % ganska bra: https://t.co/9f3Xi9uapR https://t.co/uJBPagO3DE https://t.c
@RobertoBurioni infatti un coro anche uno dei primi episodi di superdiffusione, a marzo https://t.co/tBIq8zPD3b
RT @HelenBranswell: Here's some evidence that shows what happens when #Covid19 makes its way into a choir https://t.co/ZTjTpm5swd & this gr…
@marticabre @askatasuno I el maig el @DrEricDing deia això: https://t.co/Wcgrj8AvHd
RT @observatorio14: 10b. «"The 2.5-hour singing practice provided 👉several opportunities for droplet and fomite transmission, including mem…
RT @observatorio14: 10b. «"The 2.5-hour singing practice provided 👉several opportunities for droplet and fomite transmission, including mem…
RT @observatorio14: 10b. «"The 2.5-hour singing practice provided 👉several opportunities for droplet and fomite transmission, including mem…
10b. «"The 2.5-hour singing practice provided 👉several opportunities for droplet and fomite transmission, including members sitting close to one another, sharing snacks, and stacking chairs at the end of the practice👈…» https://t.co/QTPOMjTzYM
@MarieFleur3 Je me rappelle : https://t.co/e171yZEIAd https://t.co/pcUjGsce7K
@gala_mistral Espero que la CDC le parezca más fiable https://t.co/evrSpD5EAI
@Orla_Hegarty @ppwone Washington choir cases in March: https://t.co/gV8LA8NjHw Restaurant/bar in Ireland: "at the premises where the dinner party was, a table adjacent to the party had six people, all of whom became positive for the virus." https://t.co
@joost_schreve @itosettiMD_MBA @DrTomFrieden @NickKristof Also singing classes https://t.co/rwCm582RPQ
@nitzanb5 @horowitz_b @CoronaVirusHebr @rutihersh @PhysicsRocks3 יש סיפורי מקהלות וקירונה שאני מכיר. הנה לינק: https://t.co/haXy7spOf1
RT @atla_fan: 9/ Sumado al canto en el interior... el infame brote de coro de Washington en el que se identificaron 53 casos de las 61 pers…
11/ Please avoid indoor events as much as possible. If you must be indoors, a mask must be worn BY EVERYONE, ALL OF THE TIME. If we ALL do this, we can significantly reduce the potential for spread. https://t.co/1NTZNcJt8d
۱۹/ ۸- موسیقی: مارس ۲۰۲۰: در تمرین آواز یک گروه کر در #آمریکا که ۶۱ نفر حضور داشتند، ناقل شماره یک باعث آلوده کردن ۵۲ نفر از اعضای گروه شد که ۳ نفر آنها در بیمارستان بستری شدند و ۲ نفر هم فوت کردند. https://t.co/MIYR1v6Mzj https://t.co/vyMv3YaGTu
۱۷/ ۸- موسیقی: مارس ۲۰۲۰: در تمرین آواز یک گروه کر در آمریکا که ۶۱ نفر حضور داشتند، ناقل شماره یک باعث آلوده کردن ۵۲ نفر از اعضای گروه شد که ۳ نفر آنها در بیمارستان بستری شدند و ۲ نفر هم فوت کردند. https://t.co/MIYR1v6Mzj https://t.co/IRAxJnh1yx
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
9/ Sumado al canto en el interior... el infame brote de coro de Washington en el que se identificaron 53 casos de las 61 personas que asistieron; 3 fueron hospitalizados y 2 fallecieron. https://t.co/IrduUf2Jm8
Two out of every 60 people dead from COVID are not good statistics.
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AliNouriPhD: 4. CDC: Another choir super-spreading event: following practice, 32 confirmed; 20 probable secondary cases. "The act of si…
@aasmundm Du har rett i at det var Skagit county. Smitte ved korøvelse forutsetter jo at noen faktisk er smittet da. https://t.co/fzUWd8N6F3
RT @DrEricDing: One infected person spreads the virus to 52 other people (87%) at choir practice. Crazy. This is why indoor socializing is…
High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice ... https://t.co/3hdROPR1Gk via @CDCgov
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
@realreporter and certain persons, who release an order of magnitude more particles than their peers, have been referred to as superemitters and have been hypothesized to contribute to superspeading events https://t.co/Ae5mlIVNIV #bced #CovidChoirs #bcpo
@realreporter Aerosol emission (of #covid19) during speech has been correlated with loudness of vocalization @CDCgov https://t.co/Ae5mlIVNIV #bced #CovidChoirs #bcpoli #bcelection2020
@realreporter Choir practice attendees had multiple opportunities for droplet transmission from close contact or fomite transmission, and the act of singing itself might have contributed to SARS-CoV-2 transmission @CDCgov https://t.co/Ae5mlIVNIV #bced #b
@realreporter .@CDCgov thought choirs were so dangerous in spreading #covid19 did a post on it & Dr Henry & #bcndp ALLOW them? High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020 https://t.
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
@Franklin_Graham @minnis_dr @SamaritansPurse @opmthebahamas Great thread here. Singing indoors was deadly for this choir. Sad.
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
RT @AbraarKaran: 9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61…
9/ Adding to the singing indoors...the infamous choir outbreak from Washington in which 53 cases were identified out of 61 people who attended; 3 were hospitalized and 2 died. https://t.co/zDp35CLrNI
All this shows is that air is released more slowly and steadily during singing--and there's no reason to suspect that singing isn't dangerous, when we have evidence like this: https://t.co/iJLiUSEOnH