High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020

@EWoodhouse7 Remember this? A church choir practice in Washington state on 10 March 2020 was (allegedly) a Covid superspreader event. 2 died. 🤔 https://t.co/3DwNWKPmcI

@RandPaul Of the 61 people attending this choir practice 53 became ill with Covid and 2 died. Common sense is not fear. https://t.co/hf692oRNeo

RT @PhineasGregg: @RandPaul @AndyBeshearKY Following a 2.5-hour choir practice attended by 61 persons, including a symptomatic index patien…

RT @PhineasGregg: @RandPaul @AndyBeshearKY Following a 2.5-hour choir practice attended by 61 persons, including a symptomatic index patien…

@RandPaul @AndyBeshearKY Following a 2.5-hour choir practice attended by 61 persons, including a symptomatic index patient, 32 confirmed and 20 probable secondary COVID-19 cases occurred (attack rate = 53.3% to 86.7%); three patients were hospitalized, and

@CrabbBrendan @MackayIM Been saying this since the pandemic started as it was raised by many experts at the beginning eg : https://t.co/Y8089i5ppb

RT @mtlteadrinker: @joeyfox85 @jvipondmd Wow! We had well publicized evidence of airborne transmission by May 2020: https://t.co/YWUT5IKrUh

@joeyfox85 @jvipondmd Wow! We had well publicized evidence of airborne transmission by May 2020: https://t.co/YWUT5IKrUh

@DIYTips4 @AllisonPearson If you don't like CNN for some reason there are plenty of other sources on it, e.g. https://t.co/uZirIdHURL

@maddold52 @AllisonPearson Not all of them obviously, COVID doesn't have a 100% death rate. But yes, people died. Like that one I linked to in Washington State where 87% of the choir were infected, several hospitalised, two dead. https://t.co/uZirIdHURL

RT @kirkmurphy: @JReinerMD This is heartbreaking. The sentinel Skagit Choir tragedy -reported by the choir on March 17 2020- could have bee…

RT @kirkmurphy: @JReinerMD This is heartbreaking. The sentinel Skagit Choir tragedy -reported by the choir on March 17 2020- could have bee…

@JReinerMD This is heartbreaking. The sentinel Skagit Choir tragedy -reported by the choir on March 17 2020- could have been averted with prior warning. That event was also more than enough to notify all Americans to mask up. https://t.co/5QcHPcQpbC

@ELarcinese @MatthewDavidH I should note this famous case showed evidence of "airborne" SARS-Cov2 causing infections but again it's hard to know whether the virus that was spread by pure aerosolized virus or lots of respiratory droplets spread by singing o

@WoodG252000 May 2020. MAY 2020. And here we still are, in 2023 https://t.co/dsK5nBtJiG

RT @genxer22: @gabbystern @annie_sparrow Why did WHO wait for the coroner's report on the first mass #COVID19 in the U.S? Seattle reporte…

@gabbystern @annie_sparrow Why did WHO wait for the coroner's report on the first mass #COVID19 in the U.S? Seattle reported suspicious pneumonia in Jan. Some of us in Canada recall SARS1. Kirkland WA choir Mar 17, 2020- "aerosols" mentioned in MMWR re

RT @lithohedron: We knew almost nothing about COVID at the time, but on March 17th 2020 we got nearly definitive proof that COVID was airbo…

RT @lithohedron: We knew almost nothing about COVID at the time, but on March 17th 2020 we got nearly definitive proof that COVID was airbo…

RT @lithohedron: We knew almost nothing about COVID at the time, but on March 17th 2020 we got nearly definitive proof that COVID was airbo…

We knew almost nothing about COVID at the time, but on March 17th 2020 we got nearly definitive proof that COVID was airborne in the form of a superspreader event at a choir practise in Washington State https://t.co/NZqVkiozgf

@Policentos @CathyYoung63 @katrosenfield @rebelempiricist It’s right above her post in the thread but if you need your own personal link here it is:

@rebelempiricist @katrosenfield https://t.co/VUqcGNU6C8 https://t.co/zlqurWAtiA It was not an isolated incident btw, there are other case studies showing similar spread from group singing practice, often in church. But go off &accuse pub health of b

@NateSilver538 One church choir event with 61 people, 32 caught covid and 2 died. https://t.co/evJcEbeMz3

@NateSilver538 https://t.co/1iTXCrPzxO

@JamesSurowiecki Can they not remember this at all? Seems like it was a closure that was not crazy. https://t.co/f2s5GYKqEn

@NateSilver538 https://t.co/jAag5X4spt

@D__Melb @LadyDoctorSays What about this one https://t.co/Ch7sYy2MjK

High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following Exposure at a Choir Practice — Skagit County, Washington, March 2020 https://t.co/I4YUXWuzi8 @DaystarJoni @RobertKennedyJr whine about churches being closed for no reason during COVID-19. Why don't you talk about pu

sometimes really?!

RT @healthyrespect1: @GojiraSpouse @this1wierdgirl @elendraug How on earth is this even possible in 2022? Can no-one read? Back in 2020 a s…

RT @healthyrespect1: @GojiraSpouse @this1wierdgirl @elendraug How on earth is this even possible in 2022? Can no-one read? Back in 2020 a s…

RT @healthyrespect1: @GojiraSpouse @this1wierdgirl @elendraug How on earth is this even possible in 2022? Can no-one read? Back in 2020 a s…

RT @healthyrespect1: @GojiraSpouse @this1wierdgirl @elendraug How on earth is this even possible in 2022? Can no-one read? Back in 2020 a s…

@GojiraSpouse @this1wierdgirl @elendraug How on earth is this even possible in 2022? Can no-one read? Back in 2020 a single case infected 52 and killed 1 in a single practice. Forward this to the grossly negligent people responsible. https://t.co/dsK5nBtJi

@Leftylockdowns1 People still in denial about the ease with which covid is spread by singing? Seems there’s no limit to how in denial people can be… https://t.co/dsK5nBtJiG

@HousatonicLive https://t.co/f6Rffvz5B5

@BirkieGal @misanthropoetry This is an interesting analysis of how choirs can foment superspreading. Case study of 61 person-choir. 52 confirmed/probable COVID infections, 2 deaths. Choir is very high risk and show choir is particularly arduous. It’s quite

@Muniz_Benny @rollerderbing @elisaperego78 The link above is to a non-peer reviewed paper by the following authors, of which only one is a doctor. I'd recommend researching other reports on this incidence. The one listed here is much more in-depth. https:/

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

@Scribulatora Regretfully, singing is a high-risk activity. https://t.co/h7kRFXft28

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

Mr Nonsense & Mr Marvelous: "The theory of viral transmission through aerosol" #badebm https://t.co/mSedfvCJf5

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @joeyfox85: @moog77 Thought you might find this review interesting: https://t.co/tZzygr45S3

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

Kovidvēstures pārrakstīšana satrauc ne tikai "antivakserus"

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @jljcolorado: A good summary of (some, not all the reasons) why the Dingwall et al. paper trying to re-write history on airborne transmi…

RT @alexselby1770: Covid-19 history-rewriting bothers me. Heneghan, Jefferson and Axon, Dingwall et al make a big stretch as they seek to d…